I've been the one who plays close to the vest You give an inch or two But you never give the rest But when I look into her eyes It puts me to the test She tells me forever is the shelf life of love Let's take it down and see what we're made of When darkness binds me, her beauty reminds me Of heaven up above She tells me forever is the shelf life of love I hid my heart in a safe behind the wall It's been locked up so long I'm not sure it's there at all But when I look into her eyes This fortress starts to fall She tells me forever is the shelf life of love Her smile breaks through the things I'm frightened of When darkness binds me, her beauty reminds me Of heaven up above She tells me forever is the shelf life of love Her gentle faith captures me And brings me back again Believing in the shelf life of love But when I look into her eyes This fortress starts to fall