When I lost Tommy I won Billy as a consolation prize The love he gave me Really swayed me It was shining in his eyes Oh, Billy poor Billy Was my consolation prize 'Cause I love Tommy I used Billy Hoping that he would not get wise Each time I meet him I mistreat him And tell him such a pack of lies Oh, Billy poor Billy Was my consolation prize Although Billy was tender And Billy was always there I kept wishing Tommy's lips They were mine all mine to share Then I hurt Tommy Lost his sweat heart But when he call I realized That I loved Billy Only Billy What a passing in disguise Oh, Tommy, hey Tommy Go ahead and get yourself A consolation prize (repeat)