In New York City Back When I was young And colorful I saw a girl I doubled back Was she the one? Lady Black Cigarette? She rolls her own I should’ve known Would you care To come and talk To me alone? Your smile seems so familiar Like maybe we’d met before If we had, girl, I was a fool to forget The deep end sounds inviting And she's already in Should I stay dry? Or should I get wet? My hotel Two o’clock Dizzy from All the fun Said goodnight And Lady Black Was on the run Called her back Later on But she was already done Bloody red Lioness I should’ve known When did this go one sided? I didn’t fall in alone Sometimes I wish I’d never met you at all If love goes unrequited Can we really call it love? Do I hang on? Or should I let go? Should I let go? Your smile seems so familiar Like maybe we’d met before If we had, girl, I was a fool to forget The deep end sounds inviting And she's already in Should I stay dry? Or should I get wet? Do I hang on? Or should I let go? Should I let go?