Say it ain't so Why would you go? You promised to wait for me Right there on the other side Eyes on the prize The Moon in your eyes You promised to wait for me And I know you'd never lie No, you wouldn't lie I noticed much to my surprise No, you wouldn't lie You meant it, what you said that night When you whispered, I love you On an island called hope But baby, I'm not sleeping anymore And you whispered, I love you On an island called hope But baby, I'm not sleeping anymore The lights on the stairs They shine on your hair You promised to wait for me You said I was your man So warm to the touch You promised so much You promised to wait for me But you tucked tail and ran No, you wouldn't lie I noticed much to my surprise No, you wouldn't lie You meant it, what you said that night No, you wouldn't lie I noticed much to my surprise No, you wouldn't lie You meant it, what you said that night When you whispered, I love you On an island called hope But baby, I'm not sleeping anymore And you whispered, I love you On an island called hope But baby, I'm not sleeping anymore I do much better when I do it my way I do much better when I do it my way When you whispered, I love you On an island called hope But baby, I'm not sleeping anymore And you whispered, I love you On an island called hope But baby, I'm not sleeping anymore