We're all alone in this world Nail me to the cross in the darkest alley I said the Prince of Peace doesn't have to know about it Say three Hail Marys, turn around, pray about it Come on, nail me to the cross in the darkest alley Heartbeats through the dark that spread like a poison And the tears ran hot like black tar of emotion Inherit the earth when no words are spoken And the sky like a veil was our wounds torn open And as she lie dying in a dark alleyway Her lips were ruby red And her eyes were morning green But she whispered to me Come closer, come closer And as I knelt down beside With her dying breath, she said to me I'll wait for you forever And ever, and ever And ever Come on, nail me to the cross in the darkest alley I said the Prince of Peace doesn't have to know about it Ah, say three Hail Marys, turn around, pray about it Ah, come on, nail me to the cross in the darkest alley Heroine She's my heroine She said she's my heroine She's my heroine And I was crying Hail Mary God, I scream Hail Mary On my knees I cry Hail Mary Oh Lord, I scream Hail Mary Oh, listen to me Hail Mary I just cried Hail Hail Mary Mary, Mary Mary Hail Mary Marry me, marry me, marry me