We were two broken hearts in the darkness we both pretend In my mind you were her in your fantasies I was him But hearts heal I guess cause tonight I feel something new And I realize by the look in your eyes you’re feeling it too Let’s leave the lights on tonight It’s you I want to hold tight Why don’t I just close the door We won’t pretend anymore We’ll let them old memories die We’ll be just you and I Somehow it all feels so right Let’s leave the lights on tonight I was just using you and you were just using me We made love in the dark but only to fantasies Oh I wanted her but now I find I’m wanting you And the way you touch me girl I believe you’re wanting me too