Tom: E E G#m Should’ve been open, should’ve done more C#m A Should’ve learned a lesson from the year before E G#m Should've been honest, should’ve just cried C#m A Should’ve told me there was nothing left inside [Chorus 1] B C#m A Now the road keeps rollin’ on forever B C#m A And the years keep pulling us apart B C#m A We lost something, I still wonder what it was A A B E It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it does [Interlude] E G#m C#m A [Verse 2] E G#m You should've just broken, you should've come clean C#m A You should've been sad instead bein' so fuckin' mean E G#m It shouldn't be easy, but it shouldn't be hard C#m A You shouldn't be a stranger in your own backyard [Chorus 2] B C#m A Now the road keeps rollin’ on forever B C#m A And the years keep pulling us apart B C#m A I know it's over, I'm just sayin' this because A A B It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it does [Interlude] A A E B A A E B A A E B A E C#m E B [Verse 3] E G#m I shouldn't be angry, I shouldn't hold on C#m A I shouldn't leave messages in every little song E G#m It could've been always, it could've been me C#m A We could've been busy naming baby number three [Chorus 3] B C#m A Now the road keeps rollin’ on forever B C#m A And the years keep pulling us apart B C#m A If it's on someone, I blame the both of us A A B It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it G#m C#m It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it F#m A B E It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it does [Outro] E G#m C#m A E G#m C#m A E G#m C#m A E G#m C#m A